Suppression of the T-dependent Antibody Response Following Oral Exposure to Selected Polycyclic Aromatic Compounds in B6C3F1/N Mice
Victor J. Johnson1*, Cynthia V. Rider2, Michael I. Luster1, Cynthia J. Willson3, Shawn Harris4, Billie Stiffler5, James Blake6, Esra Mutlu2, Veronica Godfrey2, Brian Burback5, Reshan Fernando6, Suramya Waidyanatha2, Gary R. Burleson1, Dori R. Germolec2*
1Burleson Research Technologies, Inc. Morrisville, NC, USA
2Division of Translational Toxicology, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
3Integrated Laboratory Systems, LLC, An Inotiv Company, Morrisville, NC, USA
4DLH, LLC., Bethesda, MD, USA
5Battelle, Columbus, OH, USA
6RTI International, Research Triangle Park, NC, United States
* Denotes corresponding author
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22427/NTP-DATA-500-005-004-000-4
Publication
Abstract
Introduction: The ability of polycyclic aromatic compounds (PACs), most notably
benzo(a) pyrene [B(a)P], to suppress antibody responses in experimental animals
is well documented. Very little information, however, is available on the
immunotoxicity of related PACs despite their widespread presence in the
environment. Additionally, there are several weaknesses in existing
immunotoxicity databases for PACs in experimental animals, limiting their
applicability in quantitative risk assessment. Careful characterization of strong
positive and clear negative PACs is needed in order to lay the foundation for
generating robust immunotoxicity data for structurally diverse PACs that have not
yet been evaluated.
Methods: In the current study, adult B6C3F1/N female mice were treated daily for
28 consecutive days by oral administration of B(a)P to provide dose levels ranging
between 2 and 150 mg/kg bodyweight/day. In addition, phenanthrene and
pyrene, non-carcinogenic PACs, were tested at dose ranges between 12.5 and
800 mg/kg bodyweight/day and 3.1 and 200 mg/kg bodyweight/day,
respectively. Immune assessments following PAC exposure included organ
weights and immunopathology, hematology, quantification of immune cell
types in the spleen, and T-dependent antibody response (TDAR) to sheep red
blood cells (SRBC).
Results: Benzo(a)pyrene exposure resulted in significant decreases in lymphoid
organ weights, immune cell populations in the spleen and TDAR. The most
sensitive indicator for immunotoxicity from B(a)P treatment was suppression of
antibody responses, where an ~75% decrease occurred at a dose level of 9 mg/kg
bodyweight/day and ~32% decrease at the lowest tested dose of 2 mg/kg
bodyweight/day. Antibody suppression was associated with significant
immune cell loss in the spleen; however, it was clear that the suppression of
the TDAR was more sensitive than cell loss indicating that cell function impairments
were involved. Phenanthrene treatment also resulted in suppression
of the antibody response but only at dose levels ≥50 mg/kg bodyweight/day
without significant effects on other parameters, while pyrene showed no
significant immune effects.
Conclusion: Suppression of the TDAR to SRBC immunization was the most
sensitive immune endpoint being 33 times more sensitive than changes in liver
weight, a commonly used outcome for risk assessment for PACs. Benzo(a)pyrene
was the most potent PAC regarding suppression of humoral immunity whereas
pyrene did not affect the immune responses tested. These studies lay the
foundation for evaluating diverse PACs with a range of immunotoxicological
potencies.
Study Data
Study Tables - Mouse Immunotoxicity Benzo(a)pyrene (28 day)
- I01 - Animal Removal Summary (70 KB)
- I02 - Animal Removals (516 KB)
- I04 - Mean Body Weight Summary (200 KB)
- I04G - Mean Body Weight Gain (178 KB)
- I05 - Clinical Observations Summary (79 KB)
- M03 - Peripheral Blood Leukocyte Cell Differential (34 KB)
- M04 - Hematology (34 KB)
- M06 - Spleen Immunophenotyping (36 KB)
- M07 - TDAR SRBC Spleen AFC (31 KB)
- M08 - Serum IgM Antibody Titers to T - Dependent Antigen Sheep Erythrocytes (29 KB)
- M17 - Bone Marrow Cellularity (30 KB)
- PA03 - Nonneoplastic Lesion Summary with Percent Incidence (257 KB)
- PA06 - Organ Weights Summary (35 KB)
- PA10 - Statistical Analysis of Nonneoplastic Lesions (265 KB)
- PA14 - Individual Animal Pathology Data (1 MB)
- PA18 - Incidence Rates of Nonneoplastic Lesions by Anatomic Site with Average Severity Grade (258 KB)
- PA46 - Summary of Gross Pathology (420 KB)
Study Tables - Mouse Immunotoxicity Phenanthrene (28 day)
- I01 - Animal Removal Summary (84 KB)
- I02 - Animal Removals (506 KB)
- I04 - Mean Body Weight Summary (207 KB)
- I04G - Mean Body Weight Gain (168 KB)
- I05 - Clinical Observations Summary (143 KB)
- M03 - Peripheral Blood Leukocyte Cell Differential (34 KB)
- M04 - Hematology (33 KB)
- M06 - Spleen Immunophenotyping (36 KB)
- M07 - TDAR SRBC Spleen AFC (31 KB)
- M08 - Serum IgM Antibody Titers to T - Dependent Antigen Sheep Erythrocytes (29 KB)
- M17 - Bone Marrow Cellularity (30 KB)
- PA03 - Nonneoplastic Lesion Summary with Percent Incidence (222 KB)
- PA06 - Organ Weights Summary (35 KB)
- PA10 - Statistical Analysis of Nonneoplastic Lesions (230 KB)
- PA14 - Individual Animal Pathology Data (1 MB)
- PA18 - Incidence Rates of Nonneoplastic Lesions by Anatomic Site with Average Severity Grade (223 KB)
- PA46 - Summary of Gross Pathology (246 KB)
Study Tables - Mouse Immunotoxicity Pyrene (28 Day)
- I01 - Animal Removal Summary (73 KB)
- I02 - Animal Removals (516 KB)
- I04 - Mean Body Weight Summary (130 KB)
- I04G - Mean Body Weight Gain (120 KB)
- I05 - Clinical Observations Summary (87 KB)
- M03 - Peripheral Blood Leukocyte Cell Differential (34 KB)
- M04 - Hematology (34 KB)
- M06 - Spleen Immunophenotyping (37 KB)
- M07 - TDAR SRBC Spleen AFC (32 KB)
- M08 - Serum IgM Antibody Titers to T - Dependent Antigen Sheep Erythrocytes (29 KB)
- M17 - Bone Marrow Cellularity (30 KB)
- PA03 - Nonneoplastic Lesion Summary with Percent Incidence (185 KB)
- PA06 - Organ Weights Summary (32 KB)
- PA10 - Statistical Analysis of Nonneoplastic Lesions (191 KB)
- PA14 - Individual Animal Pathology Data (2 MB)
- PA18 - Incidence Rates of Nonneoplastic Lesions by Anatomic Site with Average Severity Grade (185 KB)
- PA46 - Summary of Gross Pathology (210 KB)